- Shipped
- Reading
- 3 min
Making good decisions in 4 steps

4 steps to making good decisions
Getting important decisions right rarely comes down to intuition or luck. The people who make the fewest mistakes are not more intelligent; they simply use a filtering system to strip out emotional noise and self-deception before they act.
This 4-step protocol brings together the risk management and cognitive psychology methodologies developed by key figures such as Nassim Taleb, Jeff Bezos, Gary Klein and the brothers Chip and Dan Heath (authors of the WRAP system).
If you are about to make a complex decision, try running it through this sequence before you take the plunge.
Step 1: Filter by reversibility (Jeff Bezos)
The question: Is this a "one-way door" or a "two-way door" decision?
- Two-way door decision (reversible): If it goes wrong, the consequences are minor and you can quickly get back to where you started.
- One-way door decision (irreversible): The impact is profound, permanent or extremely costly to repair.
Rule of action: If the decision is reversible, decide quickly. Getting paralysed analysing data for decisions that can be corrected is a waste of time. If it is irreversible, slow down and invest resources in the next three steps.
Step 2: Assess the risk asymmetry (Nassim Nicholas Taleb)
The question: Can I easily survive the worst possible scenario?
Look only at the relationship between your maximum loss (if it goes wrong) and your potential gain (if it goes right).
- Favourable asymmetry: The cost of being wrong is limited and entirely affordable (e.g. losing a limited budget or 20 hours of work), but the benefit if you get it right is huge.
- Unfavourable asymmetry: The benefit is small or marginal, but the mistake could be catastrophic for your health, your career or your cash flow.
Rule of action: Immediately rule out any option that carries a risk of ruin. Look for situations where mistakes cost you very little and successes are exponential.
Step 3: Carry out a pre-mortem (Gary Klein)
The question: Assuming it is a year from today and the decision has been an absolute disaster, what caused it?
The human brain tends towards excessive optimism (overconfidence bias) when it wants something to go well. The pre-mortem turns the analysis on its head by forcing you to look back from a future failure.
Rule of action: Write down on a sheet of paper the 3 main reasons that will have caused that hypothetical failure. Once you have identified them, adjust the plan today to protect yourself against those blind spots before launching the initiative.
Step 4: Seek disconfirmation (Daniel Kahneman / Charlie Munger)
The question: What data or arguments would prove me wrong?
Confirmation bias makes you look only for information that validates the option you instinctively like. To make objective decisions, you have to force yourself to do the opposite.
Rule of action: Do not accept a decision as valid until you have found at least two solid reasons against your preferred option and have been able to refute them with concrete facts.
Quick execution summary
| Step | Key concept | Tool | Action required |
| 1 | Reversibility | One-way and two-way doors | Decide quickly if you can turn back; take your time if you cannot. |
| 2 | Asymmetry | Ruin scenario vs. gain | Make sure the maximum loss is small and affordable. |
| 3 | Pre-mortem | Looking back from failure | Identify today the 3 reasons why the plan would fail in a year's time. |
| 4 | Disconfirmation | Attacking your own bias | Find 2 solid arguments against your idea. |
Leading international resources for further reading
- Farnam Street (Mental Models): Shane Parrish's library of mental models for sharpening your judgement.
- Untools: A collection of visual systems and templates for structured problem-solving.
- Clearer Thinking: Free interactive tools for identifying and neutralising cognitive biases.